![]() |
| Add caption |
December 15, 2019
November 6, 2019
Sierra Club endorsed candidates make gains in local races
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Wednesday, November 6, 2019
Media Contacts:
Christy McGillivray: 808-726-5325
Tim Minotas: 248-961-9610
Sierra Club endorsed candidates won big in last night’s elections across Michigan. The issues that drove voters to the polls in this off-year election included candidate commitments to renewable energy at the municipal level, safe affordable drinking water, environmentally sustainable development, and support for local recycling programs. Sierra Club is proud to support candidates that championed these issues.
Michael Fournier, the Sierra Club endorsed candidate for mayor of Royal Oak, sees his win as a mandate to push forward on sustainable development. Speaking with Sierra Club this morning Fournier said, “Environmental issues are top issues for our constituents in Royal Oak. We plan to be thoughtful leaders in proving that economic development and environmental sustainability are not mutually exclusive.”
The election results from last night show that candidate positions on environmental issues will also play a big role in the 2020 election. According to polling done this summer through the Yale project on climate communications, 65% of registered voters in Michigan are concerned about climate change, and 74% of voters are likely to support candidates who favor funding renewable energy. Sierra Club channels significant grassroots support to translate these polling results into election results, and last night’s wins show that we are making gains going into 2020.
Sierra Club endorsed candidate Wendy Pate, the highest vote getter across all candidates in Trenton, sees environmental issues at the heart of her campaign issues, “I campaigned for community benefit in development. The International Wildlife Refuge and the Detroit River anchor our community, and we deserve clean sustainable development that will drive Trenton forward.”
For a full list of Sierra Club endorsed candidates visit
https://www.sierraclub.org/michigan/endorsed-candidates-2019
Media Contacts:
Christy McGillivray: 808-726-5325
Tim Minotas: 248-961-9610
Sierra Club endorsed candidates won big in last night’s elections across Michigan. The issues that drove voters to the polls in this off-year election included candidate commitments to renewable energy at the municipal level, safe affordable drinking water, environmentally sustainable development, and support for local recycling programs. Sierra Club is proud to support candidates that championed these issues.
Michael Fournier, the Sierra Club endorsed candidate for mayor of Royal Oak, sees his win as a mandate to push forward on sustainable development. Speaking with Sierra Club this morning Fournier said, “Environmental issues are top issues for our constituents in Royal Oak. We plan to be thoughtful leaders in proving that economic development and environmental sustainability are not mutually exclusive.”
The election results from last night show that candidate positions on environmental issues will also play a big role in the 2020 election. According to polling done this summer through the Yale project on climate communications, 65% of registered voters in Michigan are concerned about climate change, and 74% of voters are likely to support candidates who favor funding renewable energy. Sierra Club channels significant grassroots support to translate these polling results into election results, and last night’s wins show that we are making gains going into 2020.
Sierra Club endorsed candidate Wendy Pate, the highest vote getter across all candidates in Trenton, sees environmental issues at the heart of her campaign issues, “I campaigned for community benefit in development. The International Wildlife Refuge and the Detroit River anchor our community, and we deserve clean sustainable development that will drive Trenton forward.”
For a full list of Sierra Club endorsed candidates visit
https://www.sierraclub.org/michigan/endorsed-candidates-2019
##
The Sierra Club is America’s largest and most influential grassroots environmental organization, with more than 3.5 million members and supporters nationwide and over 150,000 in Michigan. In addition to protecting every person's right to get outdoors and access the healing power of nature, the Sierra Club works to promote clean energy, safeguard the health of our communities, protect wildlife, and preserve our remaining wild places through grassroots activism, public education, lobbying, and legal action. For more information, visit www.sierraclub.org/Michigan.
Paid for by Michigan Sierra PAC (109 E. Cesar E. Chavez Ave. Lansing, MI 48906)
Labels:
endorsement,
politics
October 31, 2019
Court Ruling On Enbridge Line 5 Leaves Great Lakes At Risk
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Thursday, October 31, 2019
Sean McBrearty, Campaign Coordinator, Oil & Water Don’t Mix
The Court of Claims ruling that Public Act 359 of 2018 establishing a tunnel authority is legal does not change the fact that Enbridge’s Line 5 pipelines continue to pose an unacceptable risk to the Great Lakes and Michigan’s economy.
Given that the future of the Great Lakes is at stake immediate review and action by Governor Whitmer and her administration is required. Because the previous administration of former Gov. Snyer attempted to contract away the rule of law, a legal appeal of today’s ruling on the proposed tunnel deal for Enbridge Line 5 in the Straits of Mackinac by the Michigan Court of Claims is particularly critical and necessary.
Today’s decision is disappointing because it momentarily allows the deal for a new tunnel in the Straits to make its way through the many authorizations and permits requires to be placed in the public trust soils under the Great Lakes. The decision does nothing to address and protect the Great Lakes from these dangerous, corroding, dented 66-year-old pipelines. Enbridge’s pipelines will continue transporting 23 million gallons of oil a day through the Straits, even as the most dangerous time of year approaches when gales and ice cover in the Straits makes oil spill response in the event of a Line 5 rupture or leak impossible. Enbridge would like everyone to think that a Straits oil tunnel is the solution to the problem of their dangerous pipelines. But they have refused to even commit to constructing a tunnel or submit it for normal review under Michigan law and walked away from negotiations with the governor after she reasonably demanded that any tunnel must be constructed within two years.
##
August 22, 2019
Community and Environmental Organizations Push Michigan to Reject DTE’s Long-Term Energy Plan
FOR IMMEDIATE
RELEASE: Aug. 21, 2019
Contact:
Ivan Moreno, Natural Resources Defense Council, imoreno@nrdc.org, 312-651-7932
Rachel Perkins, Byrum & Fisk Communications, rperkins@byrumfisk.com, 517-333-1606
Rachel Perkins, Byrum & Fisk Communications, rperkins@byrumfisk.com, 517-333-1606
Community and Environmental Organizations Push Michigan to Reject
DTE’s Long-Term Energy Plan
LANSING – Environmental and community organizations today are calling
for Michigan’s Public Service Commission to reject the proposed long-term
energy plan from DTE following testimony from experts revealing how DTE’s plan
will hold back a transition to cleaner, more affordable energy. Experts ranging
from energy economists, renewable experts, and health professionals submitted
testimony detailing significant flaws in DTE’s proposal.
Advocates argue that the plan would unnecessarily increase costs, rely
too heavily on fossil fuels that should be retired much earlier, increase
racial and economic inequity, and not invest enough in the clean energy
resources that customers are increasingly demanding. Environmental and
community organizations also call for a more transparent, fair, and inclusive
planning process that would hold the state’s utilities accountable to Michigan
customers.
The full case filing including testimony can be found here:
https://sforce.co/2KMZROU.
The following are
reactions from environmental, conservation and community organizations on DTE
Energy’s proposed Integrated Resource Plan:
“We need a plan that puts people first, with health, affordability and
community power at the forefront,” said Jackson
Koeppel, Executive Director of Soulardarity.
“DTE’s proposal is a transparent attempt to push the cost of their bad
investments and abysmally poor management onto the low-income communities and
communities of color they have been dumping pollution and rate hikes on for
their entire career. DTE is intentionally ignoring community solar and other
local solutions because they care more about how much money their investors
will make next quarter than the lives of the millions of people they claim to
serve.”
“DTE’s plan is supposed to be a vision for powering homes and
businesses across the state. Instead, it’s left Michigan’s environmental
justice communities feeling stripped of power,” said Michelle Martinez, statewide coordinator for the Michigan Environmental Justice Coalition.
“If we want real climate justice, the process must change, must be inclusive,
and must hold DTE accountable.”
"DTE’s IRP treats both carbon emissions and cost impacts on
ratepayers as an afterthought, instead of a priority that needs to be
addressed," said Alexis Blizman,
Policy Director at the Ecology Center.
"DTE must expand energy efficiency, as well as include greater investments
in clean, renewable energy, like wind and solar, to protect ratepayers against
both the harmful impacts of continuing the use of fossil fuels, as well as the
price volatility of natural gas. The Commission should reject DTE's proposed
IRP and send them back to create a plan that protects both people and planet.”
“DTE has an opportunity to embrace a clean energy future for Michigan,
but by submitting a plan that fails to seriously look at solar and wind power,
battery storage, energy efficiency and demand response, it did not give itself
that chance,” said Margrethe Kearney,
a senior attorney with the Environmental
Law & Policy Center. “This plan holds onto the old way of doing
business, outdated strategies that don’t give DTE the flexibility to integrate
clean, cost-effective renewables that benefit both Michigan’s economy and the
environment.”
“DTE’s IRP is consistent with a century-old monopoly stuck in
traditional solutions,” said John
Richter, Policy Analyst at Great
Lakes Renewable Energy Association. “DTE has proposed utility-owned wind
parks in just enough quantity to meet their legal obligations and the demands
of their largest customers for green energy. While the GLREA welcomes the
proposed renewable energy facilities, the assumptions formed in the overall
plan are faulty and mired in the past. This plan needs substantial revision.”
“DTE’s current proposal to keep coal online for the next 20 years will
have vast and far-reaching implications on the health, safety, and well-being
of families across Michigan,” said Kindra
Weid, RN and Coalition Coordinator of MI
Air MI Health.
“Integrated resource plans are incredibly important for mapping out
our energy future. It's critical that the plans the MPSC ultimately approves
are based on sound analysis,” said Charlotte
Jameson, energy policy and legislative affairs director of Michigan Environmental Council. “DTE
submitted a plan riddled with flaws that bias the outcome away from clean,
renewable energy. These errors are clear to see, especially when you compare
their plan with the one Consumers Energy submitted. As intervenors charged with
protecting Michigan’s environment and residential ratepayers, we will continue
to weigh in on each step of this IRP process to make sure we get the best
outcome for Michigan’s residents.”
"DTE’s long-range plan fails to rein in exploding
electricity costs that are burdening families and businesses,” said Lisa Wozniak, executive director of the
Michigan League of Conservation Voters.
“Michiganders are seeing the negative effects of climate change every day --
from flooded basements and farm fields to spreading algae in the Great Lakes
and scorching droughts. It is time for DTE to move aggressively toward clean,
renewable energy instead of delaying investments in solar and wind power and
opening new, expensive gas plants."
“DTE’s plan yet again shortchanges their customers’ clean energy
future in favor of more expensive fossil fuels,” said Ariana Gonzalez, senior energy policy analyst for the Natural Resources Defense Council.
“They clearly ignored the massive tide of criticism from their last proposal
that led to a billion-dollar gas plant. This is why we must set a precedent in
this case to ensure clean, safe and affordable energy for all.”
"Instead of protecting clean water, clean air, and our
communities, DTE chooses to invest in their pocketbooks by doubling down on
expensive, polluting fossil fuels," said Theresa Landrum, Detroit resident and activist with Sierra Club. “We call on the Michigan
Public Service Commission to reject DTE's polluting energy plan. Alternatively, we ask the MPSC to require
them to design a plan that protects Michiganders and those living in the most
heavily impacted communities by investing in cheaper and cleaner renewable
energy sources, efficiency programs, and storage technology.”
“DTE's plan to keep
relying on coal plants for the next two decades fails to account for the
health, climate, and financial impacts of burning coal,” said Shannon Fisk, Managing Attorney of Earthjustice’s Coal Program. “DTE
overestimated the costs of replacing coal plants with renewables, storage, and
efficiency because the company relied on flawed and outdated assumptions,
instead of actual market data. Michiganders would benefit most, in terms of
cost and health, from aggressive replacement of coal plants with cost-effective
and reliable clean energy.
“DTE’s plan favors its own
expensive power plants over a truly robust process to ensure cleaner and more
affordable energy for Michigan customers. I’ve seen utility commissions reject
resource plans for far less egregious missteps," said Joe Daniel, senior energy analyst at the Union of Concerned Scientists. “DTE overestimated the cost of
renewables, underestimated the benefits of efficiency, all the while ignoring
risks associated with the way it operates its existing fleet of coal-fired
power plants. The Michigan Public Service Commission should send this plan back
to the company and insist that DTE take seriously its obligation to fairly
evaluate all resource options, especially earlier investments in renewable energy
and energy efficiency."
"Solar and other clean energy options have quickly become some of
America's lowest cost resources, and every Michigander should be able to
benefit from these affordable, healthy, homegrown options. Instead, DTE is
trying to double down on polluting gas and get away with offering only a very
small utility-controlled green power program that will cost customers a premium
when it should be delivering savings," said Will Kenworthy, Midwest Regulatory Director with Vote Solar. "This expensive plan
will put solar out of reach for many low-income families, seniors on fixed
incomes, environmental justice communities and others who shouldn't be shut out
from the clean economy, which is why we're joining together with allies today
to urge a stronger, healthier and more resilient path forward for DTE."
###
July 23, 2019
Sierra Club Responds to Today’s Line 5 Enbridge Lawsuit
For Immediate Release
Tuesday, July 23, 2019
Media Contact: Anne Woiwode (517)-974-2112
Sierra Club Responds to Today’s Line 5 Enbridge Lawsuit
LANSING, MI--In response to a lawsuit filed today against Enbridge in Wisconsin, Sierra Club said the potential court-ordered shutdown of Line 5 there means any negotiations for an Enbridge Line 5 oil tunnel in Michigan would only end up increasing the risk of a pipeline rupture in the Great Lakes.
The Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa filed suit against Enbridge to force the decommissioning and removal of the Line 5 pipeline from the tribe’s reservation. The action followed two years of failed mediation talks between the tribe and Enbridge and six years of Enbridge’s unauthorized operation of Line 5 following the expiration of its easement agreement the Bad River Band.
“The takeaway from today’s development should be for Governor Gretchen Whitmer to immediately drop any thought of a proposed oil tunnel or other action focused on keeping Line 5 operating in the Great Lakes and as a risk to Michigan,” said Anne Woiwode, Sierra Club Michigan Chapter Chair. “Delay is not our friend and the oil tunnel is not a solution to protecting the Great Lakes and other Michigan waterways from a Line 5 spill.”
Enbridge’s Line 5 pipeline in Wisconsin runs across 12 miles of sensitive habitat in the Bad River Reservation. Enbridge has continued to operate the pipeline for six years since easements allowing it to maintain the Reservation right-of-way expired in 2013, and today’s action seeks to bring the company’s unauthorized presence to an end.
“We have seen in Wisconsin how Enbridge has dragged out a lengthy process that left the Bad River watershed at extreme risk from an aged Line 5 pipeline. With so much at stake, Michigan can’t chase Enbridge’s oil tunnel vision because there is no end in sight that protects the Great Lakes, “ said Woiwode. “This only reinforces the need for support of Attorney General Dana Nessel’s legal action to begin the process of decommissioning Line 5 in Michigan.”
##############
The Sierra Club is America’s largest and most influential grassroots environmental organization, with more than 3.5 million members and supporters. In addition to protecting every person's right to get outdoors and access the healing power of nature, the Sierra Club works to promote clean energy, safeguard the health of our communities, protect wildlife, and preserve our remaining wild places through grassroots activism, public education, lobbying, and legal action. For more information, visit www.sierraclub.org.
*******************************************************************************
Anne Woiwode, chair
Sierra Club Michigan Chapter
Conservation Policy Committee
July 15, 2019
Open Letter to Oakland Co Commissioner Nash on Lead and Copper Rule
July 10th, 2019
Dear Commissioner Nash:
We appreciate our long working relationship with you as a former volunteer leader with the Sierra Club, and your work to protect water quality in Oakland County. Your work to stop sewage overflows and address nonpoint source pollution is important and aligns with the Sierra Club’s goals for protecting water quality.
However, your current position on the Michigan Lead and Copper Rule is at odds with ours. We are writing to clarify the Sierra Club’s position on the Michigan Lead and Copper Rule (MLCR). Sierra Club supports the MLCR as proposed. The reformed MLCR outlaws partial lead service line replacements and requires the state’s utilities to eventually replace all the lead and copper service lines in Michigan. Public education and notification requirements were also included in the reformed MLCR. All of these measures have the support of Sierra Club, and we are working hard to assure that these are implemented statewide.
Michigan is leading the nation as the first state to mandate the removal of all lead and copper service lines, ban the partial replacement of lead service lines (with an exception for extreme circumstances), and require water utilities to pay for the entire lead service line replacement. As you know, Sierra Club joined with many other organizations in seeking to assist the people of Flint after the disastrous poisoning of hundreds of thousands of people because of the disturbing policies of the Snyder administration. The measures in the MLCR cannot make up for the damage done to the residents of Flint, but they are an important step towards addressing the racially charged injustices that lead to the poisoning of a city.
In this important regard, the MLCR aligns with the Sierra Club’s position on environmental justice. Children and those living in neighborhoods with high rates of poverty and aging infrastructure face the greatest risk, and their health and safety must not be compromised by weakening the MLCR. Residents of communities with aging infrastructure are disproportionately people of color and/or low-income, magnifying the importance of environmental justice concerns and accessible public notification/education materials. The MLCR works to address these inequalities.
There is no safe amount of lead in drinking water, and due to the life-long effects of lead poisoning, support of the MLCR is particularly important to Sierra Club members. Michigan can never again allow its children and citizens to be poisoned by drinking lead contaminated water, and the Sierra Club backs the revised MLCR’s mandate to get the lead service lines out of the ground.Sierra Club asks that instead of litigating against the MLCR that you join us in supporting the MLCR and implementing it. Furthermore we ask you to join us in advocating for federal and state funding to assist with the implementation of the MLCR for any communities that cannot bear the cost of lead service line replacement. If you have any questions or need additional information please feel free to contact us.
Sincerely,
Gail Philbin, Michigan Chapter Director
Anne Woiwode, Michigan Chapter Chair
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
109 E. Cesar Chavez Ave. (formerly Grand River) • Lansing, Michigan 48906 • (517) 484-2372
www.michigan.sierraclub.org
109 E. Cesar Chavez Ave. (formerly Grand River) • Lansing, Michigan 48906 • (517) 484-2372
www.michigan.sierraclub.org
Labels:
agriculture,
Flint,
toxics
June 5, 2019
PRESS RELEASE: NTSB Line 5 Anchor Strike Report Released Amid Calls for Immediate Action by Governor, Attorney General
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Wednesday, June 5, 2019
Media Contact: David Holtz 313-300-4454/david@davidholtz. org
NTSB Line 5 Anchor Strike Report
Released Amid Calls for Immediate
Action by Governor, Attorney General
Citizens groups today called on Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Attorney General Dana Nessel to take immediate steps to shut down Enbridge’s Line 5 oil pipelines in the Straits of Mackinac in the wake of shocking details contained in a newly released National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigative report into a near-disastrous 2018 anchor strike.
The May 31 NTSB report, carried Tuesday in the trade publication Maritime Executive, blames a series of crew errors and defective equipment aboard the Erie Trader for causing the damaging anchor strikes as the tug and barge navigated up to 8-foot seas and 30-knot winds through the icy Straits. It wasn’t until more than a day after the April 1 anchor strike—when the Erie Trader approached its Indiana destination after sailing from the Straits through Lake Michigan that the ship’s captain noticed they had been dragging anchor.
“This report shows there is no regulation or law short of eliminating the pipeline that Michigan can pass to protect the Great Lakes from a catastrophic Line 5 pipeline rupture ,” said David Holtz, Oil & Water Don’t Mix spokesperson. “Michigan must act on this new evidence. Only shutting Line 5 down can prevent an oil pipeline rupture and it is urgent that the governor and attorney general immediately use their authority to protect Michigan and the Great Lakes.”
Under an agreement with the State of Michigan, Enbridge is required to shut down Line 5 oil transport during certain dangerous conditions, but didn’t do so until several days after the anchor strike was first discovered. In the aftermath of the anchor strike, Michigan also banned anchor deployment in the Straits, but as the NTSB report indicated there were already anchor restrictions in place when the Erie Trader sailed through the turbulent Straits, unknowingly dragging 540 feet of heavy chain and one of its two anchors behind it.
“Passing anchor bans and signing swiss cheese agreements with Enbridge are simply rearranging deck chairs on this Titanic disaster in the waiting,” said Holtz. “You cannot read the NTSB report and conclude anything other than an immediate and permanent shut down of Line 5 is the appropriate and necessary action to take. Every day that pipeline sits in the Straits is a day closer to disaster.”
The day of the anchor incident, most of the ship’s crew was off in observance of Easter Sunday while the captain was unaware that his ship was dragging a six-ton anchor across the lakebed, rupturing electrical pipelines and damaging Enbridge’s 66-year-old oil pipelines, according to NTSB investigators.
Other findings in the report, include:
- The Erie Trader had two anchors, port and starboard, but the crew only checked that the port anchor was secure after mooring overnight near the Soo Locks and departing the next day on Easter Sunday for the Mackinac Straits. A crew member, according to the report, indicated that the anchors were secure but actually failed to check the starboard anchor, which was recently repaired but had been previously out of service since 2017.
- Meanwhile, it appears the starboard anchor remained deployed as the Erie Trader headed to the open water behind a Coast Guard ice breaker amid heavy winds and seas. Those strong winds, high waves and noise from breaking ice may have masked the sound of the anchor chain and ship’s anchor dragging, according to the report. The report concludes that the weight of the nearly 18,000-pound anchor chain and six-ton anchor dragging through turbulent waters likely overwhelmed anchor braking and safety devices. The NTSB report also found that the starboard anchor brakes, which had been recently repaired, were not properly adjusted.
- The American Transmission Corporation, owner of the electrical lines in the Straits, first discovered a problem with the lines at 5:31pm on April 1 but it took two more days to notify the Coast Guard. It took Enbridge two weeks to visually inspect the pipeline and initially they claimed Line 5 hadn't been struck by the anchor.
Gov. Whitmer is currently negotiating a potential oil tunnel in the Straits but is concerned that construction will take many years leaving the oil pipelines there a continuing risk. The State of Michigan has approved permits for installation on 201 anchor screw supports on the twin pipelines in the Straits which are screwed into the lakebed and hold the pipeline 2 to 4 feet off the bottom, raising concerns that an anchor fluke could easily snag the now elevated pipeline.
##
Oil & Water Don’t Mix is a broad campaign of organizations, citizens and businesses across Michigan who are working to keep oil out of our Great Lakes by shutting down the dangerous Line 5 Pipelines in the Straits of Mackinac. The campaign fights for clean water and air, Indigenous rights, reducing pollution, sustainable economies and protecting sporting, tourism, and jobs that are dependent on our water and Pure Michigan way of life. Learn more at www.oilandwaterdontmix.org.
Oil & Water Don’t Mix Steering Committee
Chippewa Ottawa Resource Authority, Clean Water Action, For Love of Water, Food & Water Watch, Groundwork Center for Resilient Communities, League of Women Voters of Michigan, Michigan Environmental Council, Northern Michigan Environmental Action Council, Sierra Club, Straits of Mackinac Alliance, Straits Area Concerned Citizens for Peace, Justice and the Environment, Sunrise Movement, TC350
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

